
USDA Proposes New Horse Soring Rules and Would Withdraw Its 2024 Rule. Comments Close December 14.
A proposed federal rule published Friday, November 13, 2026 would change how show horses are inspected for soring, add an on-the-spot appeal for owners and trainers, and withdraw what is left of a stricter rule from 2024. The public can comment through Monday, December 14, 2026.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture wants to rewrite its rules against soring, the practice of hurting a horse's legs or hooves so that it steps higher in the show ring. The department's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service, known as APHIS, published the proposal in the Federal Register on Friday, November 13, 2026.
APHIS says the changes would make inspections consistent and give owners, trainers and exhibitors more due process. Humane World for Animals, a group that has pushed for stricter rules, calls the proposal a rollback. Both are describing the same document, and anyone can read it and comment on it.
What soring is
APHIS calls soring "a cruel and inhumane practice used to accentuate a horse's gait." It names Tennessee Walking Horses and racking horses as the breeds most affected. The federal Horse Protection Act makes it illegal to show, exhibit or sell a sore horse, or to transport one to or from a show, exhibition, sale or auction, according to the agency's page on the law.
Enforcement leans on inspectors chosen by the events themselves. Show managers may appoint Designated Qualified Persons, who are licensed by horse industry organizations that USDA certifies, to examine horses. USDA inspectors attend events to check compliance and to watch those inspections, the agency says.
What the proposal would do
APHIS lists these changes in its announcement:
- more training for the industry inspectors, taught by experienced equine practitioners, with an apprenticeship, evaluation before and after licensing, and conflict-of-interest safeguards
- uniform inspections that include swabbing, blood testing, a wider movement exam, and removal of a horse's pads for first-place horses and when soring is suspected
- a ban on masking agents, such as sedatives and topical numbing agents, that hide soring
- stronger rules against interfering with an inspection
- a requirement that two APHIS veterinarians inspect a horse independently and agree before the person responsible for the horse is told it is out of compliance
- an immediate appeal, at the event, to a neutral veterinarian serving as an appeals official
- removal of the "scar rule," which a federal court found likely exceeded USDA's authority
- clearer duties for show management when a horse is found sore
Under the proposal, management would have to disqualify a sore horse only from the class it was inspected for, and not from the whole event, according to the Federal Register notice.
What happens to the 2024 rule
The proposal would also withdraw the remaining parts of a rule APHIS completed in 2024. That rule was published on Wednesday, May 8, 2024 and was due to take effect on February 1, 2025. Among other things, it would have ended the industry inspector program and barred the pads and action devices used on Tennessee Walking Horses and racking horses.
It did not take effect as planned. The Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration Association sued, and on Friday, January 31, 2025, U.S. District Judge Matthew J. Kacsmaryk of the Northern District of Texas ruled that USDA had exceeded its authority on four of the five provisions the group challenged, American Farriers Journal reported. The judge upheld the end of the industry inspector program. USDA then postponed the rule several times. Agriculture commissioners from 11 states and the American Horse Council asked the department to withdraw it. One objection was that its definition of a show was broad enough to cover donkeys, mules, state fairs and 4-H shows, the journal reported.
The new proposal keeps the industry inspectors and adds training and oversight.
What critics say
Humane World for Animals, formerly the Humane Society of the United States, said in a statement that the proposal "would perpetuate the failed system of industry self-policing." The group and the Humane World Action Fund sued USDA earlier this year, saying the department had shelved rules and procedures needed to enforce the law. They said the new proposal is not the result of a ruling in that case. Both back a bill in Congress, the Prevent All Soring Tactics Act.
How to comment
Comments are open through Monday, December 14, 2026. Online, open docket APHIS-2026-0067 on regulations.gov, select the Documents tab and choose Comment next to the proposed rule. By mail, write to Docket No. APHIS-2026-0067, Regulatory Analysis and Development, PPD, APHIS, 5601 Sunnyside Ave., Beltsville, MD 20740. A comment can support the proposal, oppose it or suggest changes.
What it means here
The Horse Protection Act is a federal law, so it covers horse shows, exhibitions, sales and auctions in California as it does anywhere else. State rules touch the same ground. California's Equine Medication Monitoring Program lists soring agents among the substances prohibited at public shows and sales, according to the Department of Food and Agriculture.
Owners, trainers, show managers, farriers and veterinarians in the Bay Area have the same 30 days to comment as everyone else.
Read APHIS's summary of the proposed rule
From Saved by the Saddle
Saved by the Saddle runs free horsemanship programs for military veterans and at-promise youth at Ocean View Stables in Daly City, and is building R&R: Rescue and Rehab, its horse rescue program. No horse is in its care yet: a vet and farrier on call, a quiet space for a new horse, a written intake standard and funding for a decade or more of care come first.
Sources: Federal Register, "Horse Protection," proposed rule (Friday, November 13, 2026); USDA Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service, "USDA Announces Proposal To Strengthen Enforcement of the Horse Protection Act" (Thursday, November 12, 2026); USDA Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service, "2026 Horse Protection Proposed Rule"; USDA Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service, Horse Protection Act page; American Farriers Journal, "U.S. Department of Agriculture Opens Comments to Amend the Horse Protection Act" (Thursday, November 12, 2026); Humane World for Animals, "USDA proposes sweeping rollback of protections against cruel practice of horse soring" (Friday, November 13, 2026); California Department of Food and Agriculture, Equine Medication Monitoring Program
