
Berkeley Researchers Put Veterans on a River and Measured Awe. Here Is What They Found.
A UC Berkeley study followed 72 veterans and 52 Bay Area teenagers on white-water rafting trips. A week later their stress and PTSD symptoms were lower, and the feeling that predicted the change was awe. The study had no control group, and its authors say so.
At the end of each day on the river, the rafters filled out a short diary. It asked them to rate, from 0 to 10, how much they had felt six things: awe, amusement, contentment, gratitude, joy and pride.
The people holding the pencils were military veterans and teenagers from underserved Bay Area neighborhoods. The people who wrote the diary were psychologists at UC Berkeley, and they were after something more specific than whether a day outdoors feels good. They wanted to know which feeling does the work.
Their answer, published in the journal Emotion in 2018, was awe. With a federal task force now recommending that the outdoors have a place in veterans' care, this Bay Area study is worth reading for what it found and for what it could not.
The study
The lead author was Craig Anderson, then a doctoral student at Berkeley, working with Maria Monroy and the psychologist Dacher Keltner. Beginning in 2014 they partnered with the Sierra Club, which ran the trips.
The published study covers 124 people who rafted in the summers of 2015 and 2016: 72 veterans and 52 young people. Most went for a day or two on the South Fork of the American River. A dozen veterans spent four days on the Green River in Utah, Berkeley's news office reported.
Participants answered questions about well-being, stress and PTSD symptoms before the trip and were asked again a week after it.
What changed
A week after rafting, the groups reported on average:
- a 29% reduction in PTSD symptoms
- a 21% decrease in general stress
- a 10% improvement in social relationships
- a 9% improvement in life satisfaction
- an 8% increase in happiness
Then came the part the diaries made possible. When the researchers compared the six emotions, awe was the one that predicted who improved. The other five did not, once awe was accounted for. The teenagers improved more than the veterans.
"It's the active ingredient that explains why being in nature is good for us," Anderson told the news office.
A second study, also published in Emotion, followed 119 Berkeley undergraduates through two weeks of daily diaries. No rafts were involved. Time in nature was the experience most likely to bring on awe, and awe again went with a better sense of well-being.
What the study cannot show
The authors are direct about the limits, and the limits matter.
- No control group. Everyone went rafting. No comparison group stayed home, or did something else strenuous together.
- Cause is not established. The paper says its findings cannot prove that awe caused the improvement. Time away from work or school, exercise and company were all part of the same days.
- One week. The follow-up came a week later. Nothing here says how long the change lasted.
- Missing answers. About 70% of participants completed the follow-up.
- Self-report. The results rest on questionnaires.
The paper calls for experiments with comparison groups matched for things like physical effort. The clinical guideline that the VA and the Defense Department issued in 2023 is in the same place. It finds insufficient evidence to recommend for or against nature experiences, recreational therapy or animal-assisted therapy as treatments for PTSD.
Why it is still useful
A finding does not have to be proof to be a good lead, and this one points at something cheap. Awe does not require white water. In the undergraduate study it turned up on ordinary days outdoors.
For veterans on the Peninsula, the outdoors is close and mostly free. County parks waive their entry fee for veterans, and a lifetime federal pass costs nothing. The San Francisco VA has taken groups of veterans into the Golden Gate National Recreation Area on guided outings.
After the study, Anderson went on to postdoctoral research at the San Francisco VA, California magazine reported in 2018, hoping to build time in nature into PTSD recovery programs.
The same caution applies in the water and around horses. Saved by the Saddle has written about what research shows on surf therapy and on horses and PTSD. In both cases the evidence is promising and unfinished.
Veterans in crisis, and those worried about one, can reach the Veterans Crisis Line at any hour by dialing 988 and pressing 1, or by texting 838255.
Read Berkeley's account of the study
From Saved by the Saddle
Horsemanship, not therapy. Saved by the Saddle's programs are educational, experiential and wellness-focused. They are not medical, psychological or physical therapy, and not a substitute for care from a licensed health professional.
Heroes and Horses, Saved by the Saddle's free program for veterans, meets as Coffee and Horsemanship on the second and fourth Mondays of every month, 10:00 AM to 12:00 PM, on the ground at Ocean View Stables in Daly City. Veterans of any branch, era or length of service are welcome, Guard and Reserve included, and no horse experience is needed.
Sources: UC Berkeley News, "Nature is proving to be awesome medicine for PTSD" (Thursday, July 12, 2018); Anderson, Monroy and Keltner, "Awe in Nature Heals: Evidence From Military Veterans, At-Risk Youth, and College Students," Emotion (2018); VA/DoD Clinical Practice Guideline for Management of PTSD, quick reference guide (June 2023); California magazine, "Don't Get Down, Get Outside: How Awe-Inspiring Nature Heals" (Tuesday, July 31, 2018); Veterans Health Administration, "VHA partnership offers Veterans access to the great outdoors" (March 2021)
